After an exciting 2023-2024 season under head coach Tom Thibodeau and behind an MVP-caliber year from Jalen Brunson, the New York Knicks found themselves at a crossroads during the offseason. Fresh off a playoff run that ended in heartbreak with a second-round loss to the Indiana Pacers, the Knicks decided to make aggressive moves in an effort to chase their first championship since the 1970s. But the question now hangs heavy over Madison Square Garden: have they done enough to truly compete for a title? Or did they mortgage their future in a gamble that may not pay off?
The Bridges Gamble
In one of the most significant offseason trades, the Knicks went all-in by acquiring Brooklyn Nets guard Mikal Bridges. Bridges, who found new life in Brooklyn after being part of the Kevin Durant trade from Phoenix, was seen as a major piece for the Knicks. Known for his elite defense and improving offensive game, Bridges’ addition brings a new dynamic to a Knicks roster that already featured a strong Villanova connection with Brunson and Josh Hart. Alongside Donte DiVincenzo, the Knicks now boast three key members from Villanova’s championship-winning teams.
On paper, this sounds like a recipe for success. Brunson has established himself as the Knicks’ leader, and bringing in more familiar faces could mean increased chemistry and cohesion. But it wasn’t just Bridges’ skillset that came at a steep cost—it was the mortgage of the Knicks’ future draft assets. Brooklyn walked away with multiple first-round picks, and with a roster now built to win now, New York could be looking at a depleted future if this experiment doesn’t pan out.
The trade for Bridges underscores New York’s desperation. In a landscape where teams like Milwaukee, Boston, and Cleveland are loaded with talent and well-rounded rosters, the Knicks are staking their claim to the present. But is it enough?
A Thin Frontcourt
While the Knicks addressed the backcourt and wings, their frontcourt depth took a hit with the departure of Isaiah Hartenstein. Losing Hartenstein could prove to be a major blow as the Knicks now find themselves thin in the big-man department. Hartenstein was a key rotational piece, providing defense, rebounding, and energy off the bench behind Mitchell Robinson.
In the high-stakes, bruising battles that define playoff basketball, the Knicks could find themselves vulnerable up front. Robinson, despite his dominance as a rim protector, has struggled with injuries throughout his career, including in last year’s playoffs. When he went down, along with Julius Randle and Jalen Brunson, the Knicks’ lack of depth was exposed. Their valiant efforts were not enough to overcome the Pacers, and they missed a chance to challenge the Celtics in the Eastern Conference Finals.
Now, the question becomes whether the Knicks have enough depth and versatility in their frontcourt to survive the grind of an 82-game season and a deep playoff run. Julius Randle, for all the criticism he receives, remains a crucial piece of the puzzle. Randle was one of the first star free agents to choose the Knicks in recent years, and his ability to score and rebound at a high level has been key to their resurgence. Yet, he often finds himself the target of blame when things go wrong, despite being an All-Star and a major factor in the team’s return to relevance.
Randle’s role moving forward will be pivotal. With an improved supporting cast, he may find more space to operate and less pressure to carry the offense on a nightly basis. However, his injury history and inconsistency in big moments remain concerns. The Knicks will need Randle to elevate his game if they hope to compete with the best teams in the East.
Competing with the East’s Elite
The question on everyone’s mind is whether the Knicks’ offseason moves have propelled them into the upper echelon of the Eastern Conference. The Milwaukee Bucks, led by Giannis Antetokounmpo, remain a juggernaut. The Boston Celtics, with Jayson Tatum and Jaylen Brown, have been perennial contenders. The Cleveland Cavaliers, with their young core, look poised for sustained success. And even teams like the Pacers, who knocked the Knicks out of the playoffs last season, aren’t going anywhere.
Are the Knicks better than Milwaukee? Boston? Cleveland?
These are the teams they will need to get through if they want to make it to the NBA Finals. And while the additions of Bridges, DiVincenzo, and Hart add to their depth and toughness, the team still faces significant questions. Can Brunson continue to play at an MVP level? Can Randle remain healthy and effective in the playoffs? Will the lack of frontcourt depth catch up to them?
A Mortgage on the Future
The Knicks are banking on their present roster being enough to make a deep playoff run, but the future is uncertain. By trading away draft picks to land Bridges, they’ve put themselves in a position where winning now is not just a goal—it’s a necessity. If this team can’t deliver in the next few seasons, the Knicks could find themselves without the assets needed to make future improvements.
For now, the hype is real. New York is buzzing with the prospect of a true contender taking the floor at Madison Square Garden. But only time will tell if the gamble will pay off—or if Knicks fans will be left wondering, once again, “Isn’t enough with?”
Featured Articles
Featured Writers
